|
Vampires:
Myths and Metaphors of Enduring Evil
Thursday 22nd May - Saturday 24th May 2003
Budapest, Hungary
Session 2: Dracula
Kim Hoelzli - Exorcising the Beast:
Darwinian Influences on the Narrative of Bram Stoker’s Dracula
Department of Literature, University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario,
Canada
In The Descent of Man, Charles Darwin discusses
humanity’s progression from ape origins. Now removed from creation
in God’s image to no better than an accident of nature, humanity
loses divinity. Though conservative in the way it claimed time was necessary
for change, this idea hid the possibility of chaos; what was humanity
progressing toward? If humanity had descended from primates through a
series of accidents of nature, was it possible another accident could
cause it to slide back?
These were the anxieties plaguing the Victorian mind when Bram Stoker
published Dracula. Dracula symbolized the Victorian
fear that man wasn’t a divine entity created by a Supreme Being.
The book featured a supernatural creature described in animalistic terms.
The novel begs the question, is this creature what man is progressing
towards, or is it Darwin’s ape-man?
In the narrative of Dracula Stoker confronts this idea with religion.
Van Helsing educates his followers in the uses of religious icons and
symbols and the ways in which they can combat vampires.
Van Helsing and Dracula become parallels to Jesus and Satan. Van Helsing
has his “cross” to bear in that he must defeat Dracula or
the world will be lost. He brings the word of God with him. Dracula becomes
an insidious presence, found in the Edenic home of Lucy Westenra. He tempts
her and she succumbs. Her fall brings sorrow to those around her. It requires
a sacrifice, which comes from the body of Quincey Morris.
Stoker kills Dracula eliminating the fear, but never the fear itself.
Quincey Morris is resurrected in Jonathan and Mina’s son, Quincey.
Humanity evolves on towards something new and presumably better. Have
the heroes proved to be the fittest of the species, or have they simply
killed what they will eventually become?
Paul Marchbank
- Dracula: Degeneration, Sexuality and the Jew
Senior Lecturer, Southampton Institute, Southampton, United Kingdom
He who rejects with scorn that his own canines... [are] formidable weapons,
will probably reveal by sneering the line of his descent... For though
he no longer intends... to use these teeth as weapons, he will unconsciously
retract his `snarling muscles'... so to expose them ready for action.
(Charles Darwin, The Descent, 1, p.127).
Arguably, one interpretation of Bram Stoker's Dracula (1897)
missed by many readers is the novel's anti-Semitism: Dracula’s distinctive
physique, his parasitical desires, his `blood-sucking', his aversion to
the crucifix and Christianity, and his rapacious relation to money, parallel
stereotypical anti-Semitic nineteenth-century representations of the Jew.'
However, because no direct reference is made within Dracula which unequivocally
establishes the Count as Jewish, it would seem difficult to establish
this relationship. Nonetheless, if a comparison is made between the representation
of the vampire and the perceived image of the Jew, then a startling analogy
arises. Dracula, like the perceived image of the Jew, seemingly transmits
an inherent connection between blood and gold, between a threatening sexuality
and ethnicity which seems to confirm the novel's depiction of the vampire
as the anti-Semite's Jew. Here, the Jew is portrayed as a multi-faceted
`monster', where the Gothic novel's creation of monstrosity is never completely
unitary but is a composite of race, class, and gender'. Within the creation
of monstrosity there exists a synthesis of nineteenth-century anti-Semitic,
scientific, and sexual discourse. As such, anti-Semitism and the myth
of the vampire share a kind of, what has been called `Gothic economy'
in their ability to incorporate many `monstrous' characteristics into
one body. Under these circumstances Dracula can be viewed as the personification
of otherness - he is a polymorphous perverse reproduction of all the others
constructed by and within fictional texts, sexual science, and psychopathology.
As will be seen, Dracula's `otherness' - as sexual, as racial,
as degenerate, as criminal - altogether his stereotypical Jewishness
- threatens the stability of the British anima, sexuality, race, class,
and Empire.
This paper makes a multidisciplinary reading of Dracula which
incorporates literature, history, cultural studies, sexology and psychoanalysis
in its attempt to analyse the cultural significance and, possibly unconscious,
ideological structures within the text. Areas for discussion may include
(Eastern) Jewish migration to Britain in the late nineteenth century,
literary depictions of the Jew (i.e. Shakespeare, Dickens, Du Maurier,
Wilde etc.), the constructions of Gothic monstrosity (particularly the
links between the British Empire and the Darwinian biological theories
of eugenics, degeneration, sexology and psychology, the rise of the New
Woman) and the fear of the homosexual.
|